Nussbaum for Today: Emotional Education for Democracy

The chapter's central question

Democracy cannot be sustained by legal provisions alone. We need the emotions of citizens who rejoice in the equal dignity of others, are angry at discrimination and humiliation, and care about unfamiliar suffering. Art, education and public rituals can broaden the scope of ‘us’, but they can also incite exclusion and fear, so their critical design is important.

Read the complete essay

Martha Nussbaum extends a deep and kind hand to modern people who live by pretending to be cool and locking the door to their hearts out of fear of being hurt.

Don't be shy in the face of sadness and fear. Don't hide your tears. When you feel sad and hurt, it is a badge of your soul that you still care about someone and truly value this life.

Embrace your fragile vulnerability. And with that tender heart, please hold the hands of other vulnerable people around you. Then we will finally be not alone, but a forest of friendly humans.

Context and nuance

Martha Nussbaum connects ancient Greek philosophy, literature, law, and political philosophy to explain emotions as value judgments. Emotions are judgments that external people and things beyond my control are important to my good life, and for that very reason they reveal both human vulnerability and ethical potential.

Emphasizing political emotions does not mean replacing policy with sentimentalism. Good feelings must be combined with accurate facts, fair systems, and guarantees of rights. Compassion should not be a benevolence that looks down on someone as an object of pity, but should be the starting point for recognizing equal citizens with different abilities and common vulnerabilities.

Do not oversimplify it this way

Nussbaum does not say that we should trust all emotions as they are. Emotional judgments can be subject to incorrect beliefs and prejudices, so education and criticism are necessary. Compassion also runs the risk of seeing others as helpless victims or being quick to assign responsibility. The political value of emotions arises not when they replace institutions and examination of facts, but when they connect them with human life.

Philosophy in life

When your heart breaks in front of the pain or separation of a loved one, have you ever wished, 'I'd rather be a stone that doesn't feel anything?'

Allowing the right to mourn: When faced with a loss or separation, give yourself enough time to grieve and shed tears rather than forcing yourself to ‘forget it quickly’.

Primary-source guide

Primary guide: Upheavals of Thought, Parts I–III; Political Emotions; related capability-approach works.

Pathos Editorial · Reviewed 2026-09-12